Astronomers May Finally Have the First Picture of a Black Hole

Using a massive telescope network, scientists have data in hand that could open new frontiers in our understanding of gravity.

WESTFORD, MASSACHUSETTS - For the monster at the Milky Way’s heart, it’s a wrap.

After completing five nights of observations, today astronomers may finally have captured the first-ever image of the famous gravitational sinkhole known as a black hole.

More precisely, the hoped-for portrait is of a mysterious region that surrounds the black hole. Called the event horizon, this is the boundary beyond which nothing, not even light, can escape the object’s gargantuan grasp.

EYES ON THE PRIZE Part of the ALMA array, a set of 66 radio dishes in the Chilean desert.
PHOTOGRAPH BY NRAO, AUI, NSF

RADIO STAR A closer view of the central region of the Milky Way, where our galaxy's supermassive black hole resides.
PHOTOGRAPH BY NRAO, AUI, NSF

CENTRE STAGE A radio observatory on the ground combined forces with two space telescopes to create this image of the centre of our galaxy.
PHOTOGRAPH BY NRAO, AUI, NSF

GALACTIC GIANT A distant galaxy spied by a NASA telescope features a ring of stars around its central black hole.
PHOTOGRAPH BY NASA/JPL-CALTECH

SMALL BUT MIGHTY In addition to supermassive black holes, astronomers have found indirect evidence for lighter black holes littering various galactic hosts, including the outburst captured here by a NASA x-ray telescope.
PHOTOGRAPH BY NASA, STSCI, MIDDLEBURY COLLEGE, F. WINKLER ET AL.

EERIE GLOW Magenta spots reveal brilliant x-ray emissions from smaller black holes in the arms of a spiral galaxy.
PHOTOGRAPH BY NASA, JPL-CALTECH, DSS

MONSTER MASH Two colliding galaxies light up in multiple wavelengths as they sweep up eruptions from a supermassive black hole.
PHOTOGRAPH BY NASA, CXC, SAO, R. VAN WEEREN ET AL

JET STREAM A Hubble picture shows jets of high-speed particles spewing from the supermassive black hole at a galaxy's heart.
PHOTOGRAPH BY NASA, ESA, STSCI

COSMIC BEHEMOTH A NASA telescope captured x-ray emissions from the vicinity of one of the most powerful supermassive black holes yet seen, a giant about 3.9 billion light-years away.
PHOTOGRAPH BY NASA, CXC, STANFORD, J.HLAVACEK-LARRONDO ET AL

As the final observing run ended at 11:22 a.m. ET, team member Vincent Fish sat contentedly in his office at the MIT Haystack Observatory in Westford, Massachusetts. For the past week, Fish had been on call 24/7, sleeping fitfully with his cell phone next to him, the ringer set loud.

As the last of the data arrived at project observatories, he watched celebratory comments come pouring in on a special chat line for radio astronomers and engineers. One noted that he was about to open a bottle of 50-year-old Scotch. Another was listening to the triumphant chords of Bohemian Rhapsody.

“I’m very happy and very relieved, and I’m looking forward to getting a good night’s sleep,” Fish says.

But that sense of relief is tinged with anticipation: So much data takes time to process, and the team must wait months to find out if their massive effort was truly a success.

“Even if the first images are still crappy and washed out, we can already test for the first time some basic predictions of Einstein's theory of gravity in the extreme environment of a black hole,” says radio astronomer Heino Falcke of Radboud University in Nijmegen, The Netherlands.

Introduced in 1915, Einstein’s revolutionary theory says that matter warps or curves the geometry of space-time, and we experience that distortion as gravity. The existence of extremely massive black holes was one of the first predictions of Einstein’s theory. 

“They are the ultimate endpoint of space and time, and may represent the ultimate limit of our knowledge,” says Falcke. Yet astronomers have only circumstantial evidence that they lie hidden at the heart of every large galaxy in the universe. Even Einstein wasn’t sure that they actually existed.

According to Falcke, the first images “will turn black holes from some mythical object to something concrete that we can study.”

Gruelling Weather Watch

Getting this far took years of planning and cooperation between international partners at observatories stretching from the tallest mountain in Hawaii to the frozen terrain of the South Pole. This electronically linked network of eight observatories created a virtual telescope dish as wide as the planet.

Peering Into the Abyss
Powerful radio telescopes around the world can be synchronised to work together, enhancing the effective resolution and sensitivity beyond what any single telescope could achieve. The great distances between this collection of installations, known as the Event Horizon Telescope array, actually increases their effectiveness.

MATTHEW W. CHWASTYK, NG STAFF
SOURCE: EVENTHORIZONTELESCOPE.ORG

Known as the Event Horizon Telescope, the radio-dish network opened its eye on the heavens during a 10-day window that started on April 4.

The telescope zeroed in on two supermassive black holes: a beast as massive as four million suns called Sagittarius A*, which lies at the heart of our Milky Way galaxy, and a black hole about 1,500 times heavier at the core of the nearby galaxy M87. (Also see "Black Hole at Galaxy's Heart Launches Planet-Size 'Spitballs.'")

The Event Horizon Telescope has probed the neighbourhood of each of these behemoths before, but this is the first time the network has included the South Pole telescope and the Atacama Large Millimetre/submillimetre Array (ALMA), a group of 66 radio dishes in Chile.

ALMA sharpens the Event Horizon Telescope’s acuity 10-fold, enabling it to spot objects as small as a golf ball on the moon—and thus image the surprisingly small event horizons of the two black holes.

After years politicking for observing time and outfitting each site with critical electronic paraphernalia, the team was ultimately at the mercy of something over which they had no control: the weather.

INSATIABLE FORCE

Although their name suggests emptiness, black holes are the most densely filled objects in the universe, giving them enormous gravitational pull. Stellar black holes, formed from the collapse of giant stars, can compact the mass of ten suns to the size of New York City. Supermassive black holes at the centre of galaxies can have the mass of billions of suns. Their origin remains a mystery.

JASON TREAT AND ALEXANDER STEGMAIER, NGM STAFF. ART BY MARK A. GARLICK

SAGITTARIUS A*

In 1974 scientists discovered a very compact source of radio waves originating from a region in the Sagittarius constellation, 26,000 light-years from Earth. Dubbed Sagittarius A* (Sgr A*), the source is now known to be a supermassive black hole at the centre of our galaxy weighing more than four million suns.

1. The Singularity: According to Einstein’s equations, at the centre of a black hole a star’s entire mass has collapsed into an infinitely dense, dimensionless point called a singularity. Singularities likely don’t really exist but point to a mathematical hole in our understanding of gravity.

2. Event Horizon: The event horizon, extending some eight million miles around Sgr A*, is the boundary beyond which even light cannot escape the black hole’s gravity.

3. Static Limit: A black hole’s spin can twist space, speeding or slowing matter orbiting nearby. The static limit is the orbit where objects travelling at light speed against the black hole’s spin seem to stand still.

4. Accretion Disk: A whirling disk of superheated gas and dust likely spins at near light-speed around Sagittarius A*. The disk emits heat, radio noise, and x-ray flares but is placid compared with accretion disks in other galaxies.

5. X-Ray Jets: Though tranquil today, Sagittarius A* may have fed on a star or gas cloud a hundred times the mass of the sun as recently as 20,000 years ago. The meal produced x-ray jets blasting outward from the black hole’s poles, which are tilted 15 degrees from the plane of the galaxy.

Astronomers observe these black holes in millimetre radio waves, the wavelength band at which light can penetrate the dense concentrations of gas and dust at the centre of the galaxy and travel relatively unimpeded to Earth.

But water absorbs and emits radio waves, which means precipitation confounds observations.

To minimise this problem, radio telescopes are placed at high altitudes—the tops of mountains or high desert plateaus—but incoming clouds, rain, or snow can still take an observatory offline. Buffeting winds at these high altitudes can also shut down a telescope.

“The probability of having really good weather at every site is almost zero,” says Fish.

With only five nights available during the observing window, Fish and his colleagues met daily to make the nerve-wracking decision whether to activate the network, juggling information about current weather conditions at each site and how those conditions might change over the coming days. From the MIT facility, Fish was constantly monitoring the weather at each site on one screen and communicating with astronomers on another.

“It’s a heartbreaker if you fire off a night and [bad] weather closes in,” or if observations are cancelled on what turns out be a good night, says Shep Doeleman, director of the Event Horizon Telescope at the Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics in Cambridge, Massachusetts.

Hoping for Peanuts

Now that all five days’ worth of observations have been completed, astronomers have a long wait—and months of analysis—to find out if they’ve produced a black hole portrait.

Each observatory records so much data that it can’t be transmitted electronically. Instead, the information from all the telescopes—equivalent to the storage capacity of ten thousand laptops—has been recorded on 1,024 hard drives. The drives must be mailed to the Event Horizon Telescope’s processing centres at MIT Haystack and the Max Planck Institute for Radio Astronomy in Bonn, Germany.

The hard drives from the South Pole telescope can’t be flown out until the end of the winter season there at the end of October.

Once the data reach each processing centre, a stack of servers will perform the all-important task of combining the time-stamped signals from the eight observatories. Comparing and combining the radio waves must be done with extraordinary care, so that critical information about the size and structure of the event horizon is not lost when they are added together.

The technique of combining radio waves, known as very long baseline interferometry, is common enough in radio astronomy. But usually, the telescopes are not so numerous nor spread out over such a large area.

“We’re trying to make coherent a network the size of the globe, which is incredible when you think about it,” says Doeleman.

What astronomers hope to finally see when they add up all the signals is a halo of light surrounding a dark circle—the shadow of the black hole. The crescent of light comes from luminous gases, heated to hundreds of billions of degrees, that orbit just outside the black hole, tracing the region just beyond the event horizon.

Some simulations suggest that the halo may be brighter and thicker on one side than the other, resembling “a peanut that would not win any peanut beauty contests,” says Falcke.

Even if they can’t generate an image from this observing run, Doeleman and his colleagues already have plans to try again next year, with an even larger network of radio telescopes.

“Over the next ten to 50 years,” Falcke says, “we should even be able to make razor-sharp images as we extend the network into Africa, and ultimately, into space.”

Header Image: HEART OF THE MATTER An illustration of the supermassive black hole at the center of the Milky Way. PHOTOGRAPH BY NRAO, AUI, NSF

Discuss this article

Newsletter

Never miss a Nat Geo moment

Your email address
Submit