Earth has two extra, hidden 'moons'

First spied in the 1960s, the huge dust clouds have now been confirmed—and may affect plans for future space exploration.

Earth’s moon may not be alone. After more than half a century of speculation and controversy, Hungarian astronomers and physicists say they have finally confirmed the existence of two Earth-orbiting “moons” entirely made of dust.

As they describe in the Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, the team managed to capture snapshots of the mysterious clouds lurking just 402,336 kilometres away, roughly the same distance as the moon.

Researchers previously inferred the presence of multiple natural companions to Earth, but the dust clouds weren’t actually seen until 1961, when their namesake, Polish astronomer Kazimierz Kordylewski, got a glimpse. Even then, their presence was questioned.

“The Kordylewski clouds are two of the toughest objects to find, and though they are as close to Earth as the moon, are largely overlooked by researchers in astronomy”, says study coauthor Judit Slíz-Balogh, an astronomer at Eötvös Loránd University in Hungary. “It is intriguing to confirm that our planet has dusty pseudo-satellites in orbit alongside our lunar neighbour”.

MOON 101
What is the moon made of, and how did it form? Learn about the moon's violent origins, how its phases shaped the earliest calendars, and how humans first explored Earth's only natural satellite half a century ago.

According to the new findings, each Kordylewski cloud is about 15 by 10 degrees wide, or equal to 30 by 20 lunar disks in the night sky. This translates to an area in space about 104,607 by 72,420 km in actual size—nearly nine times wider than Earth.

The clouds themselves are enormous, but the individual particles that comprise them are estimated to measure just a micrometre across. Sunlight reflecting off these particles makes them glow ever so slightly—just like the pyramid-shaped glow of the zodiacal light that results from dust scattered between the orbits of the planets.

These satellite clouds, however, have remained hidden in the darkness of space until now simply because they are super faint.

“It is very difficult to detect the Kordylewski clouds against the galactic light, star light, zodiacal light, and sky glow”, says study coauthor Gábor Horváth, a physicist at Eötvös Loránd University. Now, using special polarising filters on their cameras, the researchers have managed to reveal the scattered light reflecting off the individual particles within the clouds.

Multiple moons

For generations, astronomers have suggested the possibility that Earth may have more than one moon. There are five specific points of stability in deep space where they figured the moons could be located.

These orbital sweet spots, known as Lagrange points, are where the gravitational pull of two orbiting objects—such as Earth and the sun—is balanced out by the centripetal force of their orbits. Here, objects remain trapped in relatively stable positions and at constant distances from both the moon and Earth.

Kordylewski first searched two of these points, L4 and L5, in the hopes of finding solid-body moons in the 1950s. Instead, he ended up revealing our first hints of dust clouds orbiting Earth.

Polarised light around Lagrange point 5 (white dot) helped reveal the presence of a dusty Kordylewski cloud.
IMAGE BY J. SLÍZ-BALOGH

From comets to meteor showers to the zodiacal band, our solar system is a dusty place. Clouds of particles strewn between the planets can be seen by keen-eyed sky-watchers under pristine, dark skies. The Kordylewski clouds, however, are not as stable as these other dusty features in deep space. The cloud’s particles are continually swapped out, making them simultaneously ever-changing and ancient.

Dust particles get trapped in the clouds due to the Lagrange balancing act and then later escape due to slight tugs from either Earth or the moon. To replenish their dust supply, the clouds draw from all types of sources for interplanetary particles, including annual events like the Perseid meteor shower. So, while the particles themselves may not reside very long in terms of astronomical time, the clouds may have been a natural fixture since the birth of the Earth-moon system.

Cosmic tumbleweeds

These dusty hazards are a bit like cosmic tumbleweeds and may end up having quite a bit of relevance for future space exploration.

For instance, certain space missions involve parking satellites at the Lagrange points, where they consume minimal fuel to stay in orbit. That includes the upcoming James Webb Space Telescope, which is due to unfurl at the Lagrange point L2 sometime in the 2020s. Space agencies have also come up with plans to use Lagrange points as transfer stations on a so-called interplanetary superhighway for missions to Mars, Horváth says.

“The investigation of the dynamics of Kordylewski clouds may very well end up being most important from the point of view of space navigation safety”, he adds.

And if Horváth and Slíz-Balogh’s hypotheses are right, there may be more of these roving clouds of dust chasing Earth, just waiting to be discovered in neighbouring Lagrange points.

RELATED: APOLLO MOON LANDING PHOTOS

Apollo 11 astronaut Edwin “Buzz” Aldrin poses with the US flag planted on the Sea of Tranquility. If you look closely, you can see Aldrin’s face through his helmet visor.
PHOTOGRAPH BY NASA

Related Articles

Discuss this article

Newsletter

Never miss a Nat Geo moment

Your email address
Submit