A fossil site in Canada has yielded the heaviest Tyrannosaurus rex specimen ever found—an animal that weighed an estimated 8,845 kilograms in life, far heftier than most elephants alive today.
The dinosaur, unveiled last week in The Anatomical Record, consists of a skeleton that's about 65 percent complete, including the skull and hips along with some of its ribs, leg bones, and tail bones. Nicknamed “Scotty,” the tyrannosaur was a senior by this species' standards, making it to at least the age of 28.
Over a thousand dinosaur species once roamed the Earth. Learn which ones were the largest and the smallest, what dinosaurs ate and how they behaved, as well as surprising facts about their extinction.
Some 68 million years ago, the Canadian landscape Scotty knew was a subtropical coastal paradise—but life was no vacation. The dinosaur's remains include a broken and healed rib, a massive growth of bone in between two teeth—a sign of infection—and broken tailbones possibly maimed by another tyrannosaur's bite.
“It was not an easy life, even for the king of predatory dinosaurs, judging by all these injuries,” says Nizar Ibrahim, a paleontologist at the University of Detroit Mercy who wasn't involved with the study.
The find suggests that large predatory dinosaurs probably got older and bigger than paleontologists would have surmised based on currently available fossils. Among the known species, T. rex is one of the best represented extinct dinosaurs, with more than 20 fossil individuals identified.
“As more specimens of those other theropods are found, we're going to find their Scottys: their particularly large, particularly old individuals,” says study leader Scott Persons, a postdoctoral researcher at the University of Alberta. “It would not surprise me that those animals turn out to increase the range of body size—potentially to overlap or even surpass what we know from T. rex.”
Scotty has actually been known to paleontologists since 1991, when its bones were dug up at a site in Saskatchewan, Canada. To celebrate this T. rex's discovery, the field crew wanted to raise a toast to the creature. By that point in the field season, all they had on hand to celebrate the occasion was a bottle of scotch—hence the nickname.
This nearly whole, deep-black skull belongs to the most complete specimen of Tyrannosaurus rex on display in Europe, an individual nicknamed Tristan Otto. With 170 of its 300-odd bones preserved, this scientifically important but privately owned skeleton is currently at the Museum für Naturkunde in Berlin, Germany. Discovered in 2010 in Montana’s famed Hell Creek Formation of the late Cretaceous, the 12-metre-long fossil took four years to excavate and prepare.
PHOTOGRAPHY BY GERD LUDWIG
It has taken more than two decades, however, for scientists to come to full grips with Scotty's remains. The animal's massive bones were firmly stuck in very hard rock, making them extremely difficult to extract for study. But once Scotty's bones were freed, Persons's team could finally reconstruct the dinosaur's age and size.
Cross-sections of its bones show that their structure is remarkably robust, resembling that of a different T. rex known to have died around the age of 28. And its main leg bone, or femur, in particular provided a vital clue to Scotty's size.
By studying many living animals, scientists have found that the wider an animal's femur, the more weight that the bone tends to hold up. Scotty's femur was a whopping eight inches across—which means that Scotty's two legs could hold up more than 8,845 kilograms, give or take a couple tonnes. When the same methods are applied to Sue, the famously complete T. rex at the Field Museum, that fossil comes out about 400 kilograms lighter.
Lean and mean
However, this bone-measuring method isn't foolproof. For one, animals don't use their skeletons to passively hold up their weight; bones also endure the forces of motion. There's some evidence that tyrannosaurs may have been faster and more agile than other groups of large predatory dinosaurs, such as the earlier allosaurs. Perhaps tyrannosaur leg bones were slightly over-engineered to take the stress of running, which would lead researchers to overshoot Scotty's actual weight.
In addition, body mass is just one way of parsing bigness, and not all predatory dinosaurs had the same dimensions. Tyrannosaurs such as T. rex appear to have had stockier builds, while other species had longer, more slender bodies. This variety, some researchers argue, may even hold within the T. rex species, which includes some more “slender” specimens.
No species demonstrates this conundrum better than Spinosaurus, a semiaquatic dinosaur that lived in what's now northern Africa about a hundred million years ago. The animal was about 15 metres long from its snout to the tip of its tail, which would make it longer than T. rex. But when estimating Spinosaurus' weight based only on femur size, it comes out at just 1,633 kilograms.
Realistically, Spinosaurus almost certainly weighed more. The dinosaur is thought to have spent much of its time in the water, letting it get away with tinier hind limbs. Also, its bones were far denser than those in other predatory species, a trait that helps maintain buoyancy in living semiaquatic dinosaurs, such as penguins.
“Spinosaurus is sort of breaking the mould,” says Ibrahim, the National Geographic grantee who rediscovered the remains of Spinosaurus. “It’s a highly specialised theropod with a unique ecology and environmental context—it’s more like a river monster.
For now, Persons's gaze will remain on land. He's continuing to study Scotty's remains in detail, starting with the tyrannosaur's dramatic eye crests and flaring “horns” on the sides of its skull.
“The big thing that everyone is talking about is just how large this particular individual is,” he says, “but my favourite part of the specimen is actually the smaller details—the little bits of weirdness.”